When it comes to artificial intelligence, independent insurance agencies often find themselves in one of two situations: either moving ahead rapidly or stuck in place. For many, it’s not the technology that is holding them back; it's the myths surrounding it.
Let’s clarify some of the most common AI myths we hear from agency teams and demonstrate how overcoming these misconceptions can lead to meaningful results.
AI is not here to take over; it’s here to reduce tedious tasks. This means alleviating your team from repetitive activities such as data entry, form filling, follow-up communications, or sifting through PDFs.
Instead of replacing people, the best AI tools elevate them, freeing up time to focus on relationship-building, sales, and strategic decisions. Think of AI as your agency’s digital assistant, not your competitor.
Agencies of all sizes can take advantage of AI. Small and midsize teams often see the biggest impact because they’re stretched thin already.
Whether it’s a chatbot on your website answering basic client questions after hours or an AI tool that summarizes loss runs or coverage comparisons, these efficiencies stack up quickly and level the playing field.
A lot of the tools your agency already uses—like your AMS, CRM, or email platform—are quietly rolling out AI features. You don’t need a massive IT budget or tech team to start seeing value.
Look for features like smart email routing, AI-generated email drafts, call summaries, or document classification. You may already have access and not be using it yet.
Some AI tools aren’t ready for prime time—but others are specifically built for the insurance world. They’re trained on carrier documents, policy forms, and real-world workflows.
The key is using AI to augment, not automate, judgment. Let the AI draft the email or summarize the endorsement—your team still has a final review. Done right, it speeds up work without compromising quality or compliance.
Start small. Try one AI-powered feature in your workflow.
That could be -
Then, ask: “Did this save us time? Did it reduce friction for our team or clients?” If yes, you’re on the right track.
AI isn’t a silver bullet—but it’s also not a boogeyman. The biggest risk isn’t that AI replaces your team. It’s that your competitors adopt it faster and pull ahead.
Let’s retire the myths, get curious, and help your team do more of the work that matters.
Want help figuring out what AI tools are right for your agency?
Take our latest Tech Assessment and get personalized insights in minutes.