Automation has become one of the biggest conversations in the insurance industry (besides AI), and for good reason. There are some incredible tools available today that can eliminate repetitive work, reduce manual data entry, and give agency employees more time to focus on their clients.
But there's something I think agencies need to be careful about when they start exploring automation.
Just because you can automate a process doesn't mean you should.
I've talked quite a bit about defining the problem before purchasing new technology, but there's another piece to that conversation that deserves just as much attention: making sure the process you're trying to automate actually makes sense in the first place.
Because if your process is inefficient, inconsistent, or unnecessarily complicated, automating it isn't necessarily going to fix those problems.
You might just end up doing the wrong things faster.
Start at the Beginning, Not the End
One of the biggest mistakes I see when agencies start exploring automation is that they already have a specific solution in mind before they've taken the time to understand the process.
They know what they want the end result to look like, which is great. You absolutely should know what you're trying to accomplish.
But then they start working backward, creating steps and workflows specifically to get to that predetermined solution.
And that's where things can go sideways.
Instead of asking, "What's the best way to accomplish this?" they're asking, "How do we make this particular automation work?"
Before you start building anything, sit down and document how the process actually works today. Start with what triggers it, identify every step involved, understand who is responsible for each part, and determine what the final result should be.
Then take an honest look at what you've documented.
Are all those steps necessary? Are employees entering the same information multiple times? Are there manual tasks that exist simply because that's how the agency has always done things?
You might discover that the process needs to be redesigned before automation should even enter the conversation.
Are You Automating Work That Doesn't Need to Exist?
Let's use non-pay cancellations as an example.
Imagine your agency has employees logging into individual carrier portals, pulling non-pay reports, identifying policies that need attention, and then manually creating tasks or contacting clients.
It's repetitive work, and on the surface, it sounds like a perfect opportunity for automation.
So you start looking for ways to automate those portal logins, download the reports, consolidate the information, and generate the necessary tasks.
But here's the question I'd ask before doing any of that:
Why are we logging into every carrier portal in the first place?
There are already solutions available that can help agencies identify non-pay activity without having employees manually retrieve reports from each carrier.
Depending on your agency's systems and carrier relationships, you may be able to eliminate much of that manual process entirely.
Now, that doesn't mean you should immediately purchase another platform. You still need to evaluate whether the solution works with your existing tech, what implementation involves, and whether it makes sense for your agency.
But the point is that we should be questioning the process itself before figuring out how to automate every step.
Otherwise, we could spend a considerable amount of time building an elaborate automation around a process that never needed to exist in the first place.
Sometimes the best automation isn't making a task faster. It's eliminating the task altogether.
Get Your Employees Involved
Here's another area where I think agencies can get themselves into trouble.
Leadership decides a process needs to be automated, evaluates a solution, and starts planning how everything will work.
But the employees who actually perform that process every day aren't part of the conversation.
That's a mistake.
Your employees can tell you things about your workflows that might never come up in a leadership meeting.
They know where information gets stuck, which steps create unnecessary work, where exceptions happen, and which processes require workarounds just to get through the day.
And sometimes what leadership believes the process looks like is very different from what employees are actually doing.
If you're trying to automate a workflow without understanding those details, you're building around an incomplete picture.
Bring the appropriate employees into the conversation early. Have them walk you through the process from beginning to end, including what happens when something doesn't go according to plan.
Then work together to determine what the improved process should look like.
There's another benefit to involving your team from the beginning: employee buy-in.
People are generally more willing to adopt a new process when they've had an opportunity to provide input, explain their challenges, and understand why changes are being made.
Instead of handing them a new system and telling them how they're going to work from now on, you're giving them a role in developing the solution.
That can make a substantial difference when it's time to implement the automation.
One Process, Not Five Different Versions
Once you've documented the current workflow, you may discover that everyone in the agency handles it a little differently.
One employee creates a task. Another sends an email. Someone else keeps a spreadsheet. And a fourth person has developed their own process that nobody else really understands.
Now imagine trying to automate that.
Which version are you going to build?
Before automating a workflow, leadership needs to establish a consistent process that employees can follow.
That doesn't mean every situation will be identical. Insurance agencies deal with exceptions all the time, and some situations will always require human judgment.
But the standard workflow should be clear.
Who owns the request? What information is required? What happens next? When does someone need to get involved? How do we know the process is complete?
Those questions need answers before you start configuring automation rules.
And while you're defining that process, make sure you're accounting for the exceptions.
What happens when required information is missing? What happens when a client doesn't respond? What happens when the automation can't complete an action?
A well-designed automation should have a clear path for those situations rather than simply failing or leaving the task unfinished.
Test the Process Before You Turn It Loose
Even after you've designed a better workflow and built the automation, you're not quite finished.
You still need to make sure it works.
And I don't just mean testing it once with a perfect example where every field is populated and everything goes exactly as expected.
Use actual scenarios your agency encounters.
Test what happens when information is missing, when a record already exists, when a request needs special handling, and when something fails.
Have the employees who will be using the process participate in those tests. They're often the ones most likely to recognize when something doesn't match how work actually needs to get done.
Start with a controlled rollout rather than immediately applying the automation across the entire agency.
Make adjustments, confirm the process is producing the intended outcome, and then expand it.
Automation can be incredibly effective at repeating instructions consistently.
That also means it can repeat mistakes consistently if you haven't taken the time to get the process right.
Build the Right Process, Then Automate It
I don't want any of this to discourage agencies from exploring automation.
Quite the opposite.
I think automation represents one of the biggest opportunities for independent agencies to improve efficiency, reduce administrative work, and create additional capacity without constantly adding staff.
But the order in which you approach it matters.
Start by understanding how the work happens today. Involve the employees who perform it. Question whether each step is necessary. Establish a consistent process, account for exceptions, and then determine where automation can provide the greatest benefit.
And don't be afraid to discover that the solution looks different from what you originally envisioned.
Know what you want to accomplish, but don't build an unnecessarily complicated process just to justify the automation you already had in mind.
The goal isn't to automate as much as possible.
It's to make your agency operate better.
You May Also Like
These Related Stories

Why Automating Carrier Statement Management Is Essential for Agency Growth

Automate Certificate Holder Cleanup with Certificate Hero


No Comments Yet
Let us know what you think